SOS8540 Explorations in Class, Power, and Inequality
SOS8540 - Explorations in Class, Power, and Inequality
About the course
Department of Sociology and Political Science (ISS), NTNU – Trondheim in collaboration with Department of Sociology – University of Bergen, Department of Sociology and Human Geography – University of Oslo and Centre Universitaire de Norvège à Paris, at Fondation Maison des Sciences de l´homme invites applications for a PhD/Research Course – “Explorations in Class, Power and Inequality” to be held in Paris 28.-30. November 2022, and a follow up seminar/webinar 26. January 2023. This is a “substance course” in the Norwegian Ph.D. System.
Course credits: 5 pts (ECTS)
Deadline for application to the course: 01. November 2022
Acceptance to the course: 02. November 2022
Deadline for submitting papers: 15. February 2023
Maximum number of students: 15
Obligatory requirements: One assignment prior to the course; active participation in the course;
paper 15 pages (+/- 10%)
Course leaders: Professors Håkon Leiulfsrud (NTNU), Johs. Hjellbrekke (UiB) and Magne
Paalgaard Flemmen (UiO)
Application and contact
Application for the course must be done via e-mail to einar.syrstad@ntnu.no. Please note that confirmation of admission will be offered based on the e-mail application to Einar Gimse-Syrstad.
Local contact person in Paris:
Yann Hascoët
Rådgiver/résponsable
administrative Centre Universitaire de Norvège à Paris
CUNP FONDATION MAISON DES SCIENCES DE L'HOMME 54
d Raspail
75006 Paris, Bureau A3-08
E-mail: yann.hascoet@msh-paris.fr
phone: +33 (0)6 70 43 55 94
See also: www.paris.uio.no, facebook.com/cunpfmsh
In case of emergency, you may also contact Håkon Leiulfsrud at his mobile phone (+47) 954 04 295.
Course objectives
The course starts out with an overview of recent developments in class and inequality research with a focus on theory, methodology and empirical applications. Rather than treating old and new theory and models as fixed we are interested in exploring the possibilities to expand the heoretical vocabulary and methodologies associated with analysis of social class, power and nequality. The course should stimulate the course participants to creativity and independence in their own research. The course is set up as a mix of lectures and workshops where course participants can problematize and develop questions in their own dissertation projects.
This course includes as major topics:
- Classical theory of social class theory and class analysis.
- Challenges to class theory, including the middle class, precarization and intersections between class, gender and ethnicity.
- Social distances between social groups, documenting objective and symbolic boundaries that form the basis of individuals’ living and working conditions in European countries.
- Recent transformations of wealth inequalities, education strategies and Europeans labour markets.
- Social class, social inequality and welfare, including topics related to inequalities in health, childhood, education and the organization of welfare systems.
The course will elaborate on concrete examples of theoretical and methodological constructionwork. The course will provide an opportunity to problematize and elaborate on theoretical and methodological issues related to the participant’s own research.
Assignments
Assignment before course start
All students are asked to submit a two-page summary of their Ph.D.-project including topics of special relevance for this course.
Final paper
The final paper/assigment is based on topics decided by the student, but should include a discussion on theoretical and methodological challenges discussed during the course or related to own research.
All papers will be evaluated by the course leaders.
Lectures
This session will provide a general overview of class theory, from its classical formulations and up to its more recent versions. The session will be organised around core themes, rather than focusing on individual theorists or schools:
- Classical theory of class
- Challenges to class theory: The differentiation of class structure
- Challenges to class theory: A polarized class structure?
- Challenges to class theory: Intersections class, gender, ethnicity
Each section will be presented with a 45 min lecture, which will aim to present the context for the problematic and then go into the various ways in which the problem is dealt with by theorists of class.
The first section focuses on the early stages of industrial capitalism, in which the first versions of sociological class theory is formulated as part and parcel of the more general problem of coming to terms with “modernity”. A hallmark of this concerns the theorisation of class as a constitutive social division in modern societies.
The second part deals with the context of the rise of the join-stock ownership form, the growth and increased bureaucratisation of the capitalist firm, and the rise of the public sector welfare state. These developments caused problems for classical theories of class, because they involved the genesis of what was called “new middle classes” - groups of experts, leaders and welfare professions that would seem to be neither capitalists nor traditional workers.
The third section deals with contemporary changes in class structure, associated with, on the hand, the increasing wealth of the “1 %”, and on the other hand, the emergence of the “precariat”. These developments seem to present us with an almost opposite problem to that discussed in the second session. The session then deals with how class theory has dealt with this polarisation.
The fourth session deals with an issue that is almost as old as class theory, but seems to attract increasing attention, which is the intermeshing of social class with other forms of inequality, notably “race”/ethnicity and gender. The session will discuss keyways in which theories of class deals with this complex problem.
The session of day 2 will focus social distances between social groups, documenting objective and symbolic boundaries that form the basis of individuals’ living and working conditions in European countries. A common denominator in the lectures is the Bourdieusian social space approach, which will be applied to contemporary contexts, but also sought reevaluated. Recent transformations of wealth inequalities, education strategies and Europeans labour markets requires rethinking the role of cultural capital, which lay at the heart of Bourdieu’s analyses of the manufacture of class boundaries, and also the relations between class, gender, and race, spatial differentiations within a national social space, and conditions of work and employment.
Inspired by Pierre Bourdieu’s social space theory, the lectures will also draw on contributions a recently published book, “Class Boundaries in Europe” (Hugrée & al 2022), which provides an overview of class relations, covering topics such as class polarisation, cultural reproduction, political orientations and globalisation.”
The session of day 3 will focus on a broader range of topics at the junction between social inequality and social inclusion, including a discussion of theory, concepts and problems addressed in different discourses of inequality, social inclusion, and welfare. The session provides an overview and insights into recent empirical research on inequality in health, education, participation and citizenship, and childhood. This session will also allow for comment from the participants on topics of general interest at the end of the session.
Contributors
Håkon Leiulfsrud, Professor of Sociology, NTNU – Trondheim. Leiulfsrud´s research has focused on social theory and topics on comparative class, welfare and inequality research including work and industrial relations, family and more recently explorations on “durable inequalities” in childhood and education.
Johs. Hjellbrekke, Professor of Sociology, University of Bergen. Hjellbrekke’s research has focused on elites, classes and social mobility.
Magne Paalgaard Flemmen, Professor of Sociology, University of Oslo. Flemmen’s research is especially concerned with the cultural and political dimensions of class divisions.
Joakim Caspersen, Research Professor/Head of Research at NTNU Social Research. Caspersen's research has focused on a broad range of issues related to social inclusion in education and special pedagogy.
Zenia Hellgren, Lecturer in political and social theory/Senior Research Fellow at the Department of Political and Social Sciences, Universitat Pompeu Fabra – Barcelona. Her research interest is primarily about policies and practices of inclusion and exclusion in diverse societies, and their implications for citizenship and social membership.
Cedric Hugrée, is Research Fellow at the National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) within the Centre de recherche en sociologie et sciences politiques de Paris (CRESPPA, Paris 8/CNRS). His work focuses on higher education inequalities in France and class inequalities in Europe.
Harri Melin, is Professor Emeritus in Sociology at University of Tampere. Melin´s work focus on social class, labour unions, industrial relations, Eastern Europe and the Nordic Model.
Emil Oversveen, is Research Fellow in Sociology at NTNU and working at the think tank, Manifest. Oversveen´s research interest is in social inequality health, technology and social theory.
Etienne Penissat, is Research Fellow at the National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) currently associated with the École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales and the École Normale Supérieure. His research focuses on social class, social categorisations, and workers’ collective action in France and Europe.
Annick Prieur, Professor, Department of Sociology and Social Work, Aalborg University. Her primary research interests are different forms of social differentiation – according to class, gender, ethnicity and sexuality – as well as processes of social marginalisation and forms of social control.
Alexis Spire is Research Director at the National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) currently associated with the École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales. His research focuses on the transformation of the state, on consent to taxation, and on inequalities in France and in Europe.
Yasmine Siblot, Professor of Sociology, Univ. de Paris 8, is a specialist on the sociology of the dominated classes, working classes and migration in Europe (France / Portugal), on gender within the working classes, developing politicization, public services and the sociology of trade unions.
Timetable
(at Fondation Maison des Sciences de l´homme)
Class Theory: Challenges and promises
10.00-10.30: Welcome
10.30-11.15: Classical theory of class and contemporary discussions. Magne P. Flemmen
11.15-11.30: Coffee break
11.15-12.00: Challenges to class theory: The differentiation of class structure Magne P. Flemmen
12.15-13.45: Lunch
13.45-14.30: Challenges to class theory: A polarized class structure? Håkon Leiulfsrud & Johs. Hjellbrekke
14.30-14.45: Coffee break
14.45-15.30: Challenges to class theory: Intersections class, gender, ethnicity. Annick Prieur.
15.30-15.45: Coffee break
15.45-17.30/17.45: Paper session
Thinking about class boundaries in Europe
10.00-11.00: Social Class in Europe. Hugrée, Penissat & Spire (New book).
11.00-11.15: Coffee break.
11.15-12.15: France: The Dynamics of internal changes within a persistent class structure. Hugrée & Siblot.
12.15-13.45: Lunch.
13.45-14.45: Norway: Stability, transformation & escalation. Magne P. Flemmen & Johs Hjellbrekke
14.45-15.00: Coffee break.
15.00-16.00: The Nordic Class Structure in a Comparative Perspective. Harri Melin.
16.00-16.15: Coffee break.
16.15-17.45: Paper session
Social Class, Social Inequality and Welfare
10.00-10.30: Social Inequality in Health- Recent trends and developments Emil Oversveen
10.30-11.00: Official discourses of welfare and inclusion in the Nordic countries Joakim Caspersen.
11.00-11.15: Coffee break.
11.15-12.15: Durable inequalities in education and childhood: A comparative case study. Håkon Leiulfsrud.
12.15-13.45: Lunch
13.45-14.30: Power, discrimination and representation. An intersectional approach to the incorporation of immigrants and ethnic minorities in European societies. Zenia Hellgren.
14.30-14.45: Coffee break.
14.45-15.30: Open session
15.30-16.30: Discussion and Conclusion
10.00-12.00: Seminar based on student papers
12.00-13.00: Lunch
13.00-16.00: Seminar based on student papers
16.00-16.30: Course evaluation